Methodology · verification detail
The counts behind section 3 of the methodology, and the data files.
| Outcome | Links | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Verified | 1,072,386 | 51.8% |
| Verified, dual affiliation (counts half) | 76,180 | 3.7% |
| Set aside: company name not written in the author's affiliation | 477,272 | 23.1% |
| Set aside: ordinary-word name without a legal suffix | 107,764 | 5.2% |
| Set aside: part of a university or public institute's own unit | 93,854 | 4.5% |
| Set aside: a place or common word that failed its stricter rule | 55,115 | 2.7% |
| Set aside: organisation excluded after review, with a published reason | 136,664 | 6.6% |
| Set aside: no longer supported by the current open record | 14,515 | 0.7% |
| Set aside: other reasons (not industry, address only, disclosures, contractors at federal laboratories) | 36,585 | 1.8% |
| Total candidate links | 2,070,335 | 100% |
A link is one university, one company and one work, counted before company grouping. The link ledger gives every link with its own reason.
Rankings and pillars (CSV) Sector indices (CSV) Award finalists (CSV) Company verification (CSV) Topic to sector map (CSV) Link ledger: every candidate link and its outcome (CSV, compressed)
Released under CC BY 4.0: reuse freely with attribution to the Industry Collaboration Index, Global Research Partnerships. Source data: OpenAlex (CC0) and ClinicalTrials.gov (public domain). The downloads hold no personal data beyond the names of award finalists already shown on the award pages.
| Organisation | Reason |
|---|---|
| Scripps (United States) | Scripps Research is a non-profit research institute, not a company |
| Chan Zuckerberg Initiative (United States) | Chan Zuckerberg Initiative and Biohub are philanthropic and non-profit research organisations |
| Sciensano (Belgium) | Sciensano is the Belgian federal public health institute (government) |
| Flanders Make (Belgium) | Flanders Make is a non-profit strategic research centre |
| ALBA Synchrotron (Spain) | ALBA Synchrotron is a publicly owned research facility |
| Canadian Light Source (Canada) | Canadian Light Source is a national research facility |
| Estácio (Brazil) | Estacio is a private university group; education providers are not counted as industry |
| Twitter (United States) | Matched from social media handles in affiliation text |
| Aflac (United States) | Aflac appears only as the name of a children's cancer centre |
| Hartford Financial Services (United States) | Matched from Hartford HealthCare (a hospital system) and the city of Hartford |
| State Street (United States) | Matched from street addresses (State Street) |
| Vanke (China) | Matched from the Vanke School of Public Health and a street address |
| NamesforLife (United States) | NamesforLife is a data artefact (taxonomic nomenclature records) |
| Flatiron Health (United States) | Matched almost only from the Flatiron Institute, a non-profit research institute |
| Artificial Intelligence in Medicine (Canada) | A WHO/ITU focus group and a hospital programme, not a company |
| California Institute of Behavioral Neurosciences and Psychology (United States) | Matched from university department names |
| Guangzhou Chemistry (China) | The Guangzhou Institute of Chemistry is a Chinese Academy of Sciences institute (government) |
| Chengdu Organic Chemicals (China) | The Chengdu Institute of Organic Chemistry is a Chinese Academy of Sciences institute (government) |
| Yangtze River Delta Physics Research Center (China) | A public research centre |
| Nofima | Nofima is a state-owned research institute; research and technology organisations are not counted as industry |
| Laboratory of Data Discovery for Health | A university research laboratory (InnoHK), not a company |
| Center for Clinical Research (United States) | Matched from university research centre names |
| Collaborative Group (United States) | Matched from study-group names |
| BioElectronics (United States) | Matched from laboratory names |
| Research Center Pharmaceutical Engineering (Austria) | A university-owned research centre |
| EURECAT Centre Tecnològic de Catalunya | Eurecat is a non-profit technology centre |
| Razi Vaccine and Serum Research Institute | Razi Institute is a government research institute |
| CEINGE Biotecnologie Avanzate Franco Salvatore (Italy) | CEINGE is a non-profit research consortium |
| Austrian Centre of Industrial Biotechnology (Austria) | acib is a publicly funded research centre |
| Thinfilm (Sweden) | Matched from 'Thin Film' in department names |
| Phoenix (United States) | Matched from the city of Phoenix |
| Tianmu Lake Institute of Advanced Energy Storage Technologies (China) | A public research institute |
| Advanced Research Center for Nanolithography (Netherlands) | ARCNL is a public-private research institute |
| Swiss Center for Electronics and Microtechnology (Switzerland) | CSEM is a non-profit research and technology organisation |
| Extreme Light Infrastructure ERIC (Czech Republic) | ELI is a European research infrastructure |
| Bioscience (China) | Generic name matched from other company names |
| Center For Remote Sensing (United States) | Matched from university remote-sensing centre names |
| NaMLab (Germany) | NaMLab is a non-profit research company |
| Carmel (Israel) | Matched from Mount Carmel (Haifa) |
| Genethon (France) | Genethon is a non-profit research laboratory |
| Ricerca sul Sistema Energetico (Italy) | RSE is a publicly owned research company for the power system |
| Advisory Board Company (United States) | Matched from advisory-board disclosures |
| Fischer (Germany) | Matched from street names (Ernst-Otto-Fischer-Strasse) |
| Rogers (United States) | Matched from surnames and a place name |
| Walker (United States) | Matched from surnames and building names |
| Piaggio (Italy) | Matched from the 'E. Piaggio' research centre and street names |
| Leidos Biomedical Research Inc. (United States) | Operates a government laboratory (Frederick National Laboratory) under contract |
| Mary Kay (United States) | Matched from the Mary Kay O'Connor Process Safety Center (Texas A&M) |
| e-Trikala (Greece) | Matched from hospital and city names (Trikala) |
| Inspire | A publicly supported innovation centre |
| Shenyang Institute of Computing Technology (China) | A Chinese Academy of Sciences institute (government) |
| Tecnologie Avanzate (Italy) | Matched from Italian department and CNR institute names |
| Qinghai New Energy (China) | Matched from a university research centre |
| Energetics (United States) | Matched from the Laboratory for Laser Energetics (University of Rochester) |
| Ariadne Diagnostics (United States) | Matched from Ariadne Labs (Brigham and Women's Hospital and Harvard) |
| Artemis (United States) | Matched from a publisher and small firms; not reliable |
| Medica (Italy) | Matched from Italian department names (Medica) |
| Sprint (United States) | Matched from a clinical study group name (SPRINT) |
| Kirchhoff (Germany) | Matched from the Kirchhoff Institute and street names |
| Mercer (Czechia) | Matched from a university institute name |
| Christie (Canada) | Matched from the Meakins-Christie Laboratories (McGill) |
| Catalyse | Matched from French laboratory names |
| Pearson (United States) | Matched from surnames |
| Singer (United States) | Matched from building names (Washington Singer Building) |
| Shibuya (Japan) | Matched from the district name Shibuya |
| BioEnergetics (United States) | Matched from laboratory names |
| Pulp and Paper Research Institute | Matched from a state key laboratory name |
| Victor (Japan) | Matched from personal names |
| Deerfield (United States) | Matched from the place name Deerfield |
| Abu Dhabi Health Services | SEHA is a public healthcare provider |
| Silicon Austria Labs (Austria) | Silicon Austria Labs is a publicly funded research centre |
| Knowledge Centre for Agriculture | SEGES is a non-profit agricultural knowledge centre |
| Know Center Research GmbH (Austria) | Know-Center is a publicly funded research centre |
| Azienda di Servizi alla Persona di Pavia (Italy) | A public social and health services agency |
| Materials Center Leoben (Austria) | Materials Center Leoben is a publicly funded research centre |
| Kompetenzzentrum Holz | Wood K plus is a publicly funded research centre |
| Ulverscroft (United Kingdom) | Ulverscroft is a charitable foundation |
| Anhanguera (Brazil) | Anhanguera is a private university group; education providers are not counted |
| Organisation de Coordination pour la lutte contre les Endémies en Afrique Centrale | OCEAC is an intergovernmental public health organisation |
| Witshealth Consortium (Pty) Ltd. (South Africa) | A university-owned company |
| AMO (Germany) | AMO is a non-profit research company |
| AC2T Research (Austria) | AC2T is a publicly funded research centre |
| Virtual Vehicle Research GmbH (Austria) | Virtual Vehicle is a publicly funded research centre |
| Ikerlan | Ikerlan is a non-profit technology centre |
| Software Competence Center Hagenberg (Austria) | Software Competence Center Hagenberg is a publicly funded research centre |
| Holst Centre (Netherlands) | Holst Centre is a research and technology organisation (TNO and imec) |
| Competence Centre on Health Technologies (Estonia) | A publicly funded competence centre |
| Spital Thurgau (Switzerland) | A hospital |
| TWI (United Kingdom) | TWI is a member-based research and technology organisation |
| BEST - Bioenergy and Sustainable Technologies (Austria) | BEST is a publicly funded research centre |
| CSC - IT Center for Science (Finland) | CSC is a state-owned research computing centre |
| East Malling Research (United Kingdom) | NIAB East Malling is a non-profit research institute |
| Sanitas (Spain) | A healthcare provider and insurer |
| Matís (Iceland) | Matis is a state-owned food research institute |
| Isola (Norway) | Matched from a hospital (Ospedale Isola Tiberina) |
| Research Institute VOLGA (Russia) | Matched from a region name (Volga) |
| Usibelli Coal Mine (United States) | Matched from a university acronym (UCM) |
| Shalom Hartman Institute | Shalom Hartman Institute is a non-profit research institute |
| LightWorks (United States) | Matched from a university initiative (ASU LightWorks) |
| ARUP Laboratories (United States) | ARUP Laboratories is wholly owned by the University of Utah; university-owned organisations are not industry |
| GWT-TUD (Germany) | GWT-TUD is TU Dresden's own transfer company (university-owned) |
| GWT-TUD GmbH (Germany) | GWT-TUD is TU Dresden's own transfer company (university-owned) |
| Fimlab (Finland) | Fimlab is a laboratory company owned by public hospital districts (public healthcare) |
| Mitre (United States) | MITRE is a non-profit that operates federally funded research and development centres |
| General Atomics (United States) | General Atomics' evidence here is almost entirely from DIII-D and inertial-fusion work it performs as operator of US government facilities; treated as a contractor-operated government laboratory, like Leidos Biomedical Research |
| Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft (Germany) | A publisher |
| Mercator Ocean (France) | Mercator Ocean International is an intergovernmental organisation |
| Fera Science (United Kingdom) | Fera Science is owned by UK government |
| Estonian Environmental Research Center (Estonia) | The Estonian Environmental Research Centre is a state research centre |
| Austrian Competence Centre for Feed and Food Quality, Safety & Innovation (Austria) | FFoQSI is a publicly funded competence centre |
| Translational Research Platform for Veterinary Biologicals (India) | A research platform of Tamil Nadu Veterinary and Animal Sciences University (university-hosted) |
| Hainan Center for Disease Control & Prevention | A provincial centre for disease control (government) |
| Bamrasnaradura Infectious Diseases Institute | A government infectious-diseases hospital |
| Cambridge Crystallographic Data Centre | The Cambridge Crystallographic Data Centre is a charity |
| Polymer Competence Center Leoben (Austria) | Polymer Competence Center Leoben is a publicly funded COMET research centre |
| Institute for Rheumatic Diseases (Japan) | Matched from university rheumatology centres (King's College London) |
| EN-FIST Centre of Excellence (Slovenia) | EN-FIST is a publicly funded centre of excellence |
| Witzenhausen-Institut (Germany) | Matched from the university town of Witzenhausen (University of Kassel) |
| Institut für Umformtechnik (Germany) | Matched from a university chair (TUM Lehrstuhl fur Umformtechnik) |
| Institut für Technische und Angewandte Physik (Germany) | Matched from university physics institutes (Kiel) |
| Scottsdale Research Institute (United States) | Matched from a hospital research institute (Scottsdale Healthcare) |
| EarthTech International (United States) | EarthTech International's registry alias is 'Institute for Advanced Studies': almost every match is IAS Princeton, DIAS Dublin or another institute |
| BioClinicum (Russia) | BioClinicum is a Karolinska building and research centre, not a company |
| Luftfartsverket (Sweden) | Luftfartsverket is the Swedish state air navigation service (a government agency) |
| Advanced Biomass R&D Center (South Korea) | The Advanced Biomass R&D Center is a research centre hosted at KAIST |
| Alexandra Institute (Denmark) | The Alexandra Institute is a non-profit research and technology organisation |
| Science Systems and Applications (United States) | Contractor staffing a US federal laboratory: at least half of its author appearances (over at least 50) also name a US federal laboratory among their own affiliations (rule applied to every US company) |
| Leidos (United States) | Contractor staffing a US federal laboratory: at least half of its author appearances (over at least 50) also name a US federal laboratory among their own affiliations (rule applied to every US company) |
| Adnet Systems (United States) | Contractor staffing a US federal laboratory: at least half of its author appearances (over at least 50) also name a US federal laboratory among their own affiliations (rule applied to every US company) |
| Global Science & Technology (United States) | Contractor staffing a US federal laboratory: at least half of its author appearances (over at least 50) also name a US federal laboratory among their own affiliations (rule applied to every US company) |
| Quantum Simulations (United States) | Contractor staffing a US federal laboratory: at least half of its author appearances (over at least 50) also name a US federal laboratory among their own affiliations (rule applied to every US company) |
| Los Alamos National Security (United States) | Contractor staffing a US federal laboratory: at least half of its author appearances (over at least 50) also name a US federal laboratory among their own affiliations (rule applied to every US company) |
| Science Applications International Corporation (United States) | Contractor staffing a US federal laboratory: at least half of its author appearances (over at least 50) also name a US federal laboratory among their own affiliations (rule applied to every US company) |
| UES (United States) | Contractor staffing a US federal laboratory: at least half of its author appearances (over at least 50) also name a US federal laboratory among their own affiliations (rule applied to every US company) |
| Scispace (United States) | Contractor staffing a US federal laboratory: at least half of its author appearances (over at least 50) also name a US federal laboratory among their own affiliations (rule applied to every US company) |
| Azimuth (United States) | Contractor staffing a US federal laboratory: at least half of its author appearances (over at least 50) also name a US federal laboratory among their own affiliations (rule applied to every US company) |
| Advanced Photonix (United States) | Contractor staffing a US federal laboratory: at least half of its author appearances (over at least 50) also name a US federal laboratory among their own affiliations (rule applied to every US company) |
| IM Systems (United States) | Contractor staffing a US federal laboratory: at least half of its author appearances (over at least 50) also name a US federal laboratory among their own affiliations (rule applied to every US company) |
| GeoControl Systems (United States) | Contractor staffing a US federal laboratory: at least half of its author appearances (over at least 50) also name a US federal laboratory among their own affiliations (rule applied to every US company) |
| Predictive Biology (United States) | Contractor staffing a US federal laboratory: at least half of its author appearances (over at least 50) also name a US federal laboratory among their own affiliations (rule applied to every US company) |
| Analytical Mechanics Associates (United States) | Contractor staffing a US federal laboratory: at least half of its author appearances (over at least 50) also name a US federal laboratory among their own affiliations (rule applied to every US company) |
| Cohort exclusion | University School (Cleveland, Ohio) is a private school, not a research university. OpenAlex attributes about 37,000 works to it, almost all of them misread affiliation strings such as 'University School of Medicine'. It is excluded from the Industry Collaboration Index as an attribution artefact. |
| Cohort exclusion | The Center for Astrophysics | Harvard & Smithsonian is a research centre, not a university; its work is not counted as a separate university in the Industry Collaboration Index. |
| Cohort exclusion | The Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique de Tunisie is a national research institute, not a university. |
Every correction request decided so far, with the evidence checked against the author's own affiliation text and the same rules as every other link. Accepted corrections are applied link by link before scoring.
| Work (DOI) | Decision | Company | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10.1002/eap.2961 | Accepted | Lynker Technologies | A company named in an author's own affiliation text; most of its authors in the open record do not name a federal laboratory, so the published contractor rule (half or more of 50+ appearances) does not apply, as for Riverside Technology. |
| 10.1002/pan3.70054 | Accepted | The Change Agency International | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names The Change Agency International (a registered business name of a sole trader consultancy), a for-profit company. |
| 10.1016/j.aaf.2021.12.004 | Accepted | Fish Ageing Services | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Fish Ageing Services, a for-profit company. |
| 10.1016/j.algal.2025.104182 | Accepted | Sea Forest | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Sea Forest, a for-profit company. Every author carrying it is also a university author, so it counts one half (dual affiliation rule). |
| 10.1016/j.gexplo.2021.106839 | Accepted | Corporate Geoscience Group, Western Mining Services | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Corporate Geoscience Group, a for-profit company. Every author carrying it is also a university author, so it counts one half (dual affiliation rule). |
| 10.1016/j.molbiopara.2023.111594 | Accepted | Beximco Pharmaceuticals | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Beximco Pharmaceuticals, a for-profit company. |
| 10.1016/j.onehlt.2025.101118 | Accepted | Beyond Essential Systems | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Beyond Essential Systems, a company limited by shares (Pty Ltd) with no charity registration when the work was published, a for-profit company. |
| 10.1016/j.techfore.2023.122588 | Accepted | Cambridge Quantum Computing, Aché, Astex Pharmaceuticals, Genentech, Glyphic Biotechnologies | The company was set aside by a matching error (trading name Cambridge Quantum); the affiliation text names it. The work already counted for the university, so this adds a partner, not a work. |
| 10.1029/2024gl112903 | Accepted | Asia Pacific Resources International | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Asia Pacific Resources International (APRIL), a for-profit company. |
| 10.1038/s41467-021-23930-2 | Accepted | Rhithroecology | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Rhithroecology, a for-profit company. |
| 10.1038/s41559-024-02617-z | Accepted | Fish Fondler | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Fish Fondler, a for-profit company. |
| 10.1038/s41586-022-05318-4 | Accepted | SciTech Environmental Consulting | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names SciTech Environmental Consulting, a for-profit company. |
| 10.1038/s41586-024-08375-z | Accepted | Fish Fondler | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Fish Fondler, a for-profit company. The work already counted for the university, so this adds a partner, not a work. |
| 10.1063/5.0061627 | Accepted | Biomechanics International | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Biomechanics International, a for-profit company. The work already counted for the university, so this adds a partner, not a work. |
| 10.1071/an20148 | Accepted | Ridley AgriProducts | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Ridley AgriProducts, a for-profit company. |
| 10.1073/pnas.2312252121 | Accepted | Swift Ecology | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Swift Ecology, a for-profit company. |
| 10.1073/pnas.2414985122 | Accepted | Fish Fondler | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Fish Fondler, a for-profit company. |
| 10.1080/1040841x.2022.2072705 | Accepted | The BioArte | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names The BioArte, a for-profit company. |
| 10.1109/mim.2025.11224807 | Accepted | ProdTech Automation, Superior Swift Technologies | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names ProdTech Automation, a for-profit company. The work already counted for the university, so this adds a partner, not a work. |
| 10.1111/csp2.70012 | Accepted | Ecosev Consultoria Ambiental | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Ecosev Consultoria Ambiental, a for-profit company. |
| 10.1111/gcb.16821 | Accepted | Biolex Consultoria Ambiental | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Biolex Consultoria Ambiental, a for-profit company. The work has 100 or more authors, so it counts toward industry works only, not toward partners. |
| 10.1139/facets-2023-0220 | Accepted | North/South Consultants | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names North/South Consultants, a for-profit company. |
| 10.1144/geochem2025-050 | Accepted | Corporate Geoscience Group | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Corporate Geoscience Group, a for-profit company. Every author carrying it is also a university author, so it counts one half (dual affiliation rule). |
| 10.1371/journal.pntd.0012780 | Accepted | Charles River Analytics, Macrobiome Therapeutics | The company was set aside by a matching error (the generic-name check rejects the whole-segment name); the affiliation text names it. |
| 10.2196/71212 | Accepted | Beyond Essential Systems | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Beyond Essential Systems, a company limited by shares (Pty Ltd) with no charity registration when the work was published, a for-profit company. |
| 10.24083/apjhm.v16i1.519 | Accepted | Ramsay Health Care | The company was set aside by a matching error (the name is written 'HealthCare' without a space); the affiliation text names it. |
| 10.2478/fprj-2025-0003 | Accepted | Ardentura Consulting | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Ardentura Consulting, a for-profit company. |
| 10.3354/esr01243 | Accepted | Ecolibrium, CheloniData, McLaughlin Research Corporation, LGL Ecological Research Associates | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Ecolibrium, a for-profit company. |
| 10.3389/fmars.2021.669135 | Accepted | Ocean Environmental, Black Bawks Data Science | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Ocean Environmental, a for-profit company. |
| 10.3389/fmars.2022.873700 | Accepted | Talma Consultancy | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Talma Consultancy, a for-profit company. |
| 10.3389/fpara.2022.950744 | Accepted | Charles River Analytics | The company was set aside by a matching error (the legal form follows a comma, which the generic-name check misses); the affiliation text names it. |
| 10.3390/ebj4010004 | Accepted | Inteligels | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Inteligels, a for-profit company. |
| 10.3390/electronics12041057 | Accepted | Tiandi Science & Technology | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Tiandi (Changzhou) Automation, part of the CCTEG group, a market-producing state-owned company. |
| 10.3390/pathogens12010095 | Accepted | Charles River Analytics | The company was set aside by a matching error (the legal form follows a comma, which the generic-name check misses); the affiliation text names it. |
| 10.3905/jwm.2023.1.198 | Accepted | Ardentura Consulting | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names Ardentura Consulting, a for-profit company. |
| 10.5751/es-12625-260319 | Accepted | The Biodiversity Consultancy | The record matched the author to the wrong company; the affiliation text names The Biodiversity Consultancy, a for-profit company. |
| 10.7717/peerj.19493 | Accepted | Riverside Technology | The company was set aside by a matching error (the legal form follows a comma); the affiliation text names it. Riverside Technology is below the published federal-laboratory contractor threshold. |
| 10.1002/edn3.70100 | Declined | John Wiley & Sons is a publisher; the published method never counts publishers as industry. | |
| 10.1007/s10488-025-01479-2 | Declined | Lived Experience Australia Ltd (company limited by guarantee) and Skylight Mental Health Inc are registered charities, so neither is industry. | |
| 10.1016/j.geomorph.2023.108852 | Declined | Airborne Research Australia is Airborne Research South Australia Limited, a company limited by guarantee registered as a charity, so it is not industry. The earlier match to Sugar Research Australia was wrong, but correcting it adds no link. | |
| 10.1111/sed.12867 | Declined | Already counted: the Chevron link on this work is verified for the university. |
Corrections, researcher opt-outs and other requests: the request page.
Independence. The index is free, public and independent. No commercial relationship with any university or company changes any position, and no one can pay to be included, excluded or moved.